History of Zimmerman Cemetery.
Was originally the graveyard for an Evangelical Methodist Church.
[Church is shown on 1875 plat map of Mahoning Township (NOTE: large file
download). It’s the “Evan. Meth. Ch.” highlighted in yellow; left center on map.]
Church building no longer exists. [NOTE: I also don’t know the name of the church yet.]
[From the Eckhart County History(K), page 236: “In 1861, the Evangelical Church was
erected between the St. John’s Union Church and New Mahoning. The Rev. Owen
Leopold served the early congregation. Later, this was the location of the Zimmerman
Cemetery.”]
Contact info:
Unknown
[NOTES: The cemetery is well maintained (strictly voluntarily) by the family that lives
next door [see below], but I’m not sure if they want to be listed as the
“contact” or not.]
If you visit the cemetery, and if you have an ancestor buried there, a small
donation toward gas and expenses might be appropriate. But be discreet;
they haven’t asked for donations as far as I know.]
Directions: Located on the north side of State Route 902, a little over ˝ mile east of
the main intersection in New Mahoning village.
The entrance is a shared private driveway with a private residence (the
large blue house), on the east side of the house. Please be courteous.
Photos of Arner gravestones at
Zimmerman Cemetery:
LUCY ANN (GROSS) ARNER, 1825-1873, (wife of
Tilghman5 Arner). [gravestone] [inscription]
LOUISA ELLEN6
(ARNER) ZIMMERMAN, 1848-1925, (daughter of Tilghman & Lucy).
+SAMUEL ZIMMERMAN,
1846-1903, (husband). [no gravestone photo yet]
ISRAEL F.6
ARNER, 1851-1889, (son of Amon5 Arner
& Anna Beltz). [gravestone]
MATILDA5 (ARNER) NOTHSTEIN, 1837-1906,
(daughter of Daniel4 Arner & Leah Strauss).
+JACOB NOTHSTEIN,
1833-1907, (husband). [their gravestone]
Zimmerman Cemetery (Mahoning, Carbon, PA). Last revision: 14 Dec 2006
The *rner Genealogy Project (Arner, Erner, Orner, Urner
Families in America)
Send e-mail with genealogy questions or comments about this
website to:
![]()
Copyright © 2006 by Joseph Erner (see
Copyright Notice)
IMPORTANT NOTE: All of the photographs are
copyrighted by the photographer.